In the game of football, kickers often fly under the radar, but their role is absolutely crucial. A single swing of the leg can mean the difference between victory and heartbreak, between making history and falling short. Whether it’s nailing a last-second game-winner, setting league records, or delivering in high-pressure playoff moments, the greatest kickers have shaped the outcome of some of the NFL’s most iconic games.
Despite their importance, kickers don’t always get the recognition they deserve. Many of them have been the backbone of their teams for years, providing reliability and clutch performances when it matters most. With that in mind, we’re ranking the 15 greatest kickers of all time, considering their accuracy, longevity, game-winning heroics, and impact on the sport.
15. Nick Lowery
Nick Lowery was a model of consistency during his 18-year career. A three-time Pro Bowler, Lowery’s accuracy and ability to make clutch kicks made him a standout, especially during his time with the Kansas City Chiefs.
14. Sebastian Janikowski
Known for his booming leg, Janikowski was a fan favorite and one of the most unique kickers in NFL history. His 63-yard field goal in 2011 tied the record at the time, showcasing his incredible power.
13. Phil Dawson
Dawson’s longevity and accuracy made him a cornerstone for teams like the Cleveland Browns and San Francisco 49ers. He remains one of the most reliable kickers to have ever played.
12. Jason Elam
A two-time Super Bowl champion with the Denver Broncos, Elam’s 63-yard field goal in 1998 tied the NFL record and demonstrated his elite skill and range.
11. John Carney
John Carney’s 23-year career speaks to his durability and skill. With over 2,000 career points, Carney is one of the most prolific scorers in NFL history.
10. Matt Stover
Matt Stover’s consistency was critical for the Baltimore Ravens during their Super Bowl XXXV championship run. With over 2,000 career points, he ranks as one of the league’s most dependable kickers.
9. Jason Hanson
Spending his entire 21-year career with the Detroit Lions, Hanson was a symbol of loyalty and reliability. His 2,150 career points rank third all-time in NFL history.
8. Stephen Gostkowski
A key part of the New England Patriots dynasty, Gostkowski’s accuracy and clutch performances earned him three Super Bowl rings and four Pro Bowl selections.
7. Gary Anderson
With a career spanning over two decades, Anderson is one of the NFL’s all-time leading scorers. His perfect 1998 season was legendary, even if it ended in heartbreak in the NFC Championship Game.
6. George Blanda
Though primarily known as a quarterback, Blanda was also an exceptional kicker. His ability to play both roles at a high level over 26 seasons is a feat unmatched in NFL history.
5. Jan Stenerud
One of only five kickers inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame, Stenerud revolutionized the position as the NFL’s first great soccer-style kicker. His contributions changed the way the game is played.
4. Lou Groza
Nicknamed “The Toe,” Lou Groza was a pioneer of modern kicking techniques. A nine-time Pro Bowler and four-time NFL champion, Groza’s impact on the game is immeasurable.
Read More: 20 Rising SuperStars to Watch in the NFL
3. Morten Andersen
The “Great Dane” is the NFL’s all-time leading scorer and a Hall of Famer. Andersen’s career spanned 25 seasons, during which he made countless clutch kicks and set multiple records.
Read More: Ranking the 30 Best NFL Quarterbacks Playing Now
2. Adam Vinatieri
Vinatieri’s name is synonymous with clutch. His game-winning kicks in two Super Bowls for the Patriots are legendary, and his longevity and accolades make him one of the best to ever play the position.
Read More: Top 14 Best Seventh-Round NFL Draft Picks of All Time
1. Justin Tucker
Widely regarded as the most accurate kicker in NFL history, Tucker combines power, precision, and poise. His 66-yard game-winning field goal in 2021 set an NFL record and demonstrated his unparalleled skill. Simply put, Tucker is the gold standard for kickers today.
Watch Now: Big plays. Fast takes. Check out TQR Shorts for the latest sports news with Zoe!
