Top 15 Best Fifth-Round NFL Draft Picks of All Time

The NFL Draft is full of surprises, with superstars often emerging from unexpected places. The fifth round, in particular, has given rise to some of the league’s most iconic players.

Here’s a look at the 15 best fifth-round draft picks in NFL history:

15. Mike Webster (1974, Pittsburgh Steelers)

Mike Webster
Openverse

The heart and soul of the Steelers’ offensive line during their dynasty years, Mike Webster is widely regarded as one of the greatest centers in NFL history. A four-time Super Bowl champion and nine-time Pro Bowler, Webster’s toughness and leadership set the standard for future generations.

14. Zach Thomas (1996, Miami Dolphins)

Zach Thomas
Wikipedia

Undersized but relentless, Zach Thomas became a cornerstone of the Dolphins’ defense. Thomas, a seven-time Pro Bowler and five-time First-Team All-Pro, has instincts and a strong work ethic that have earned him a spot in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

13. Richard Sherman (2011, Seattle Seahawks)

Richard Sherman
Openverse

An integral part of the Seahawks’ “Legion of Boom” defense, Richard Sherman’s intelligence and tenacity made him one of the best cornerbacks of his era. He’s a five-time Pro Bowler, Super Bowl champion, and a master of clutch moments.

12. Kevin Greene (1985, Los Angeles Rams)

Kevin Greene
Openverse

Kevin Greene ranks third all-time in career sacks with 160. A relentless pass rusher, Greene was a five-time Pro Bowler, two-time First-Team All-Pro, and a Hall of Fame inductee.

11. Stefon Diggs (2015, Minnesota Vikings)

Openverse

Known for his precise route running and playmaking ability, Stefon Diggs became an elite wide receiver. His memorable “Minneapolis Miracle” catch and subsequent success with the Buffalo Bills have cemented his status as a top-tier NFL star.

10. Herschel Walker (1985, Dallas Cowboys)

Herschel Walker
Openverse

Herschel Walker was a dual-sport athlete whose NFL career featured impressive rushing and receiving stats. Though famously traded in a blockbuster deal, Walker’s impact on the field and his role in reshaping teams’ futures make him an unforgettable fifth-round pick.

9. George Kittle (2017, San Francisco 49ers)

George Kittle
Openverse

One of the premier tight ends in the league today, George Kittle’s combination of blocking and receiving skills is unmatched. A multi-time Pro Bowler, Kittle’s energy and leadership have made him the centerpiece of the 49ers’ offense.

8. Shane Lechler (2000, Oakland Raiders)

Shane Lechler
Openverse

Often considered the greatest punter of all time, Shane Lechler’s career was defined by his powerful leg and remarkable consistency. A six-time First-Team All-Pro, Lechler changed the way punters are valued in the NFL.

7. Rodney Harrison (1994, San Diego Chargers)

Rodney Harrison
Openverse

A hard-hitting safety, Rodney Harrison was the backbone of several dominant defenses. A two-time Super Bowl champion with the Patriots, Harrison’s physicality and leadership earned him a spot in the Patriots Hall of Fame.

6. Mark Anderson (2006, Chicago Bears)

Mark Anderson
Wikipedia

Mark Anderson burst onto the scene with 12 sacks as a rookie, helping the Bears reach the Super Bowl. Though his career had its ups and downs, Anderson’s early impact makes him a noteworthy fifth-round find.

5. La’Roi Glover (1996, Oakland Raiders)

La'Roi Glover
Wikipedia

La’Roi Glover was a dominant force on the defensive line, earning six Pro Bowl selections and an NFL Defensive Player of the Year award. His ability to disrupt offenses as a defensive tackle was extraordinary.

Read More: The Top 15 NFL Draft Classes of All Time

4. Lester Hayes (1977, Oakland Raiders)

Lester Hayes
Raiders on YouTube

A key figure in the Raiders’ defensive success, Lester Hayes was known for his sticky coverage and innovative use of Stickum. A two-time Super Bowl champion and five-time Pro Bowler, Hayes was one of the league’s premier cornerbacks.

Read More: The 29 Most Successful NFL Seasons Ever

3. Tyreek Hill (2016, Kansas City Chiefs)

Tyreek Hill, Khaleke Hudson (51615697528)
Openverse

Nicknamed “Cheetah” for his blazing speed, Tyreek Hill is one of the most explosive playmakers in NFL history. A seven-time Pro Bowler and two-time Super Bowl champion (as of 2025), Hill’s versatility as a receiver and returner has redefined offensive strategy.

Read More: Top 14 Best Seventh-Round NFL Draft Picks of All Time

2. Jerry Azumah (1999, Chicago Bears)

Jerry Azumah
Openverse

Initially a running back in college, Jerry Azumah transitioned to cornerback in the NFL and excelled as a return specialist. A Pro Bowler and one of the best kickoff returners of his era, Azumah’s versatility made him a valuable asset.

Read More: The 30 Best Draft Picks in the History of the NFL

1. Robert Mathis (2003, Indianapolis Colts)

Robert Mathis
Openverse

Robert Mathis terrorized quarterbacks throughout his career, finishing with 123 sacks. A five-time Pro Bowler and Super Bowl champion, Mathis’s strip-sack ability was legendary, and he remains the NFL’s all-time leader in forced fumbles.

Watch Now: Big plays. Fast takes. Check out TQR Shorts for the latest sports news with Zoe!

Related Articles
Jan 7, 2007; Philadelphia, PA, USA; New York Giants running back (21) Tiki Barber carries the ball against the Philadelphia Eagles in the first quarter of the NFC Wild Card Playoff game at Lincoln Financial Field in Philadelphia, PA. The Philadelphia Eagles defeated the New York Giants 23-20 in what was reported to be Tiki Barber's last NFL game. Mandatory Credit: James Lang-Imagn Images Copyright © James Lang
15 NFL Athletes Whose Bad Investments Cost Them Everything
These 15 former NFL stars watched their fortunes crash and burn. Let their stories be a warning: not...
Read More
Apr 26, 2023; Boston, Massachusetts, USA; Boston Bruins center Patrice Bergeron (37) gets ready for a face-off during the first period in game five of the first round of the 2023 Stanley Cup Playoffs against the Florida Panthers at TD Garden. Mandatory Credit: Bob DeChiara-Imagn Images
14 NHL Captains Who Commanded Respect Without a Word
These leaders built respect through every blocked shot, every relentless shift, and every moment of grit...
Read More
Nov 6, 1977; Bloomington, MN, USA; FILE PHOTO; St. Louis Cardinals guard Conrad Dobler (66) on the sideline against the Minnesota Vikings at Metropolitan Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Herb Weitman-Imagn Images
20 NFL Stars Who Played Like They’d Never Heard of a Rulebook
Some NFL stars made their names not just with their talent, but with their total disregard for how the...
Read More
May 18, 1991; Cleveland, OH, USA; FILE PHOTO; Oakland Athletics pitcher DENNIS ECKERSLEY in action against the Cleveland Indians at Cleveland Stadium during the 1991 season. Mandatory Credit: Photo By Imagn Images (c) Copyright Imagn Images
12 Baseball Legends Who Never Buried the Hatchet
From cold shoulders to frozen relationships, these are the baseball legends who never buried the hatchet—and...
Read More
Sep 7, 1985; Atlanta, GA, USA; FILE PHOTO; Atlanta Falcons quarterback Steve Bartkowski (10) in action against the Detroit Lions at Fulton County Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Manny Rubio-Imagn Images
15 Legendary Quarterbacks Who’d Struggle With Modern Defenses
From Hall of Famers to household names, these legends lit up the league in their time but might find...
Read More
Jan 20, 1991; San Francisco, CA, USA; FILE PHOTO, New York Giants linebacker (56) Lawrence Taylor in action against the San Francisco 49ers at Candlestick Park during the 1990 NFC Championship Game. The Giants defeated the 49ers 15-13. Mandatory Credit: Tony Tomsic-USA TODAY NETWORK
The 18 Most Relentless Competitors in NFL History
They didn’t always have the prettiest stats or the smoothest style, but they refused to quit no matter...
Read More

As an Amazon Associate, The Quick Report earns from qualifying purchases.

Part of the Castaway Studios media network.