There’s no denying that Aaron Rodgers is one of the most legendary quarterbacks in NFL history, but the time may have finally come for him to hang up his cleats. At 41 years old and following two rocky seasons with the New York Jets, the organization has officially decided to move on—leaving Rodgers at a crossroads in his career.
While he’s still exploring options for the 2025 season, continuing to play might not be the best move for him. From injuries to legacy concerns, here are ten reasons why Aaron Rodgers should seriously consider retirement.
1. Declining Performance
Rodgers’ on-field production has noticeably declined. In the 2024 season, he threw for 3,897 yards with 28 touchdowns and 11 interceptions, ranking only 25th in QBR—a far cry from his MVP-caliber seasons. While still capable of brilliance, his consistency has waned.
2. Age and Physical Limitations
At 41, Rodgers is the oldest starting quarterback in the league. Despite his competitive spirit, age inevitably impacts athletic performance. His mobility and ability to evade pressure have diminished, making him more vulnerable to injuries.
3. Injury Concerns
Rodgers suffered a devastating Achilles tear just four plays into his debut season with the Jets in 2023. Although he returned in 2024, such injuries are harder to recover from at his age and increase the risk of further complications.
4. Diminished Market Value
The Jets have decided to move on from Rodgers after two disappointing seasons, leaving him without a clear path forward. While a few teams might take a chance on him, many franchises are hesitant due to his age, injury history, and declining performance.
5. Lack of Team Success
Rodgers joined the Jets with high expectations but failed to deliver playoff success. The Jets finished the 2024 season with a disappointing 5-12 record, missing the playoffs for the 14th consecutive year. Continuing his career with another struggling team may not align with his legacy.
6. Legacy Preservation
Rodgers has nothing left to prove. He is a Super Bowl champion, a four-time MVP, and a first-ballot Hall of Famer. Continuing to play amid declining performance risks tarnishing his legacy as one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time.
7. Mental and Physical Fatigue
Rodgers himself has admitted needing a “mental and physical break” from football after grueling seasons. Retirement would allow him to step away from the relentless demands of the NFL and focus on personal well-being.
Read More: NFL Starting Quarterbacks Out With Season-Ending Injuries
8. Turbulent Tenure with the Jets
Rodgers’ time with the Jets has been marked by turmoil—coaching changes, strained relationships with management, and underwhelming team performance. The instability has made it difficult for him to succeed in New York.
Read More: Every NFL MVP’s Season, Ranked From Worst to Best
9. Limited Championship Prospects
Unlike Peyton Manning or John Elway, who retired as champions, Rodgers is unlikely to end his career on a Super Bowl high note given his current trajectory and lack of suitors among top-tier teams. Continuing to play might only prolong disappointment.
Read More: The Most Overrated NFL Teams Since 2000, Ranked
10. A Chance to Leave on His Terms
Yes, the Jets are letting Rodgers go, but he has a chance to now leave on his own terms. Retirement now would allow Rodgers to exit gracefully rather than being forced out by circumstances or poor performance. He can control the narrative around his departure and celebrate an illustrious career on his own terms.
Watch Now: Big plays. Fast takes. Check out TQR Shorts for the latest sports news with Zoe!
