Not every wide receiver in the NFL has a gift for catching the ball. Some were born to run fast, trash talk, and look cool in a uniform—but when it came time to actually, you know, catch the football, things got dicey.
Whether it was nerves, bad technique, or just plain bad luck, these 14 wideouts turned simple receptions into suspense thrillers. Here are the NFL receivers who made fans hold their breath—and not in a good way.
14. Ted Ginn Jr.
Ginn could blow by defenders with ease, but finishing the play was often a whole different story. His hands were as unpredictable as a roulette wheel.
13. Braylon Edwards
For every spectacular grab he made, there were three baffling drops. The talent was never the issue—it was actually holding onto the ball.
12. Darrius Heyward-Bey
Speed? Elite. Catching the ball consistently? Let’s just say the hands didn’t get the same memo.
11. Travis Taylor
Baltimore took him high in the draft, hoping he’d be their go-to guy. Instead, they got a rollercoaster of dropped passes and missed opportunities.
10. Donte Stallworth
Stallworth had flashes of brilliance, but drops plagued him like a bad habit. You never quite knew which version of him would show up.
9. Nelson Agholor
Early in his career, Agholor’s hands were the punchline to more than a few memes. He turned it around later on, but the brick-hand reputation stuck.
8. Darius Slayton
Slayton has made some big plays—but he’s also let too many easy ones slip through. Giants fans know the heartbreak all too well.
7. Stephen Hill
Drafted for his size and speed, Hill struggled to deliver much of anything in the hands department. He was basically a highlight reel for missed chances.
6. Dede Westbrook
Westbrook was supposed to be a reliable target out of the slot. Instead, he often turned short passes into missed opportunities.
5. Devin Funchess
Built like a tight end, Funchess couldn’t consistently haul in throws that hit him right in the numbers. He looked the part but rarely played it.
4. Jacoby Jones
Jones had a few electric returns and big catches, but his drop rate made fans nervous every time the ball headed his way. The inconsistency was maddening.
3. Jerome Simpson
Simpson had one unforgettable flip into the end zone—but also a forgettable list of easy drops. The athleticism was there; the soft hands were not.
Read More: Top 18 NFL Receivers Who Catch Everything Thrown Their Way!
2. Troy Williamson
Drafted to replace Randy Moss, Williamson struggled to catch even the simplest passes. Minnesota still winces at the mention of his name.
Read More: 13 NFL Wide Receivers Who Couldn’t Catch a Cold
1. Dorial Green-Beckham
Physically gifted with a massive frame and deep-threat speed, DGB just couldn’t make the ball stick. Every game felt like a frustrating round of hot potato.
Read More: Ranking the 30 Most Unlikable NFL Wide Receivers of All Time
