Some players love the game, but hate being told what to do—especially by someone in blue behind the plate. For these guys, arguing with the umpire was practically a hobby, and staying calm wasn’t in the playbook.
Whether it was over balls and strikes, safe or out, or just general frustration, these players had a knack for making a scene. Here are 15 baseball players who always seemed a little too ready to blow their top at the ump.
15. Bryce Harper
Bryce Harper doesn’t just wear his emotions on his sleeve—he throws them directly at the umpire. If he disagrees with a call, you’re going to hear about it, probably at full volume.
14. Lou Piniella
“Sweet Lou” was anything but sweet when it came to bad calls. His legendary tantrums often included hat-throwing, dirt-kicking, and theatrical rage.
13. Milton Bradley
Milton Bradley had a short fuse, and umpires were often on the receiving end. He didn’t just argue—he combusted.
12. Carlos Zambrano
Zambrano wasn’t afraid to scream, slam his glove, or toss his hat like it owed him money. Umpires were frequent targets when things didn’t go his way.
11. Manny Machado
Machado might look calm, but the second he doesn’t like a call, he flips a switch. His stare-downs and animated protests are the stuff of dugout legend.
10. A.J. Pierzynski
Pierzynski loved chaos and wasn’t shy about confronting umps with a smirk and a snarl. If there was drama, odds are he was in the middle of it.
9. Kevin Youkilis
Youkilis argued with such intense disbelief you’d think he just witnessed a crime. His patented bat drop and headshake combo was pure theater.
8. Paul O’Neill
Paul O’Neill turned rage into an art form, especially when he thought he got hosed at the plate. His explosive reactions made water coolers fear for their lives.
7. Yasiel Puig
Puig didn’t hold back, and that included barking at umpires like they had personally wronged his family. If he thought a call was bad, the bat flip came with extra fury.
6. George Brett
While Brett’s most famous blow-up was about pine tar, he never exactly kept things low-key. When he lost it, it was full-body, old-school baseball fury.
5. Bobby Cox
Okay, not a player—but he had to be here. The all-time ejection leader practically had a reserved parking spot in the clubhouse tunnel.
4. Chris Carpenter
Carpenter didn’t just question calls—he looked like he wanted to file a formal complaint with the universe. His glares alone could melt steel.
3. David Ortiz
Big Papi usually had a smile, unless you rang him up on a pitch he didn’t like. Then came the bat slam, the hands in the air, and the classic stare-down.
Read More: MLB Umpire Faces Backlash After Questionable Calls in Yankees-Mets Game
2. Jose Bautista
Bautista never saw a strike he agreed with. His mix of dramatic pauses, eye rolls, and arm gestures made every disagreement feel like a soap opera.
Read More: Robot Umpires Make MLB All-Star Game Debut, Eye 2026 Regular Season Use
1. Brett Lawrie
Lawrie made arguing with umps look like a full-contact sport. His helmet toss alone could have taken out a small nation—and yes, it did hit the ump once.
Read More: Ranking the 20 Most Charismatic MLB Stars Ever
