The NFL has changed a lot over the years, especially when it comes to defense. Hits that used to get players standing ovations would now earn them a hefty fine, a stern letter from the league, and probably a suspension.
Some of these defenders were legends, others were chaos agents, but all of them played like the league’s rulebook was more of a suggestion. If these guys suited up in 2025, they’d be paying more in fines than they ever made in game checks.
21. Joey Porter
Porter played like every down was a bar fight and someone just insulted his mom. Today’s NFL would hit him with a fine before he even left the tunnel.
20. Bill Romanowski
Romos was notorious for crossing the line—sometimes literally, sometimes violently. He’d rack up more fines than tackles in today’s player-safety-obsessed league.
19. Rodney Harrison
Harrison made receivers think twice about running routes across the middle. In 2025, his reputation alone would probably trigger automatic penalties.
18. James Harrison
He hit with the force of a wrecking ball and the intent of a sledgehammer. The league’s wallet would empty real fast, keeping up with his fines.
17. Lyle Alzado
Alzado was a storm of fists, fury, and questionable legality. There’s no way modern rules would survive a single quarter of his play style.
16. Ndamukong Suh
Stomping on people isn’t exactly in the spirit of sportsmanship these days. Suh would need a second job just to afford the weekly fines.
15. Cortland Finnegan
The man treated every snap like it was a WWE tryout. His antics would cost him half a season’s salary before Week 5.
14. Steve Atwater
Atwater hit with the kind of violence that echoed in the upper deck. Today, he’d be flagged just for thinking about those hits.
13. Richie Incognito
Even when he wasn’t getting penalized, Incognito was living on the edge. In a league hyper-focused on image and safety, he’d be a walking violation.
12. Deacon Jones
Jones invented the head slap—a move that would get you banned from the league today. He’d probably lead the league in fines before Halloween.
11. Jack Lambert
Lambert looked like a villain in a football movie and hit like one, too. His old-school rage would be no match for today’s penalty flags.
10. Bernard Pollard
Pollard took out so many offensive stars that he earned the nickname “The Patriot Killer.” In 2025, he’d have a GoFundMe just to pay the league.
9. Vontaze Burfict
He was basically a penalty waiting to happen. The league would have him on speed dial for disciplinary meetings.
8. Greg Lloyd
Lloyd was all attitude, all the time, with zero concern for consequences. Modern refs would toss him before the second series.
7. Albert Haynesworth
One word: stomp. That infamous moment alone would cost him six figures and a suspension in today’s NFL.
6. Andre Waters
His nickname was “Dirty Waters,” which tells you everything you need to know. He’d be a walking targeting penalty in 2025.
5. James “The Hitman” Hasty
Hasty delivered hits with surgical aggression. Today’s NFL would fine him for even looking too intense.
4. Conrad Dobler
Dobler built his entire reputation on playing dirty and not caring who knew it. In today’s NFL, with its focus on player safety and image, he’d lead the league in fines and ejections, and probably enjoy every second of it.
3. Bryan Cox
He wore “I hate the Bills” hats and played like he hated everybody. The league would have a special budget just to fine him weekly.
Read More: Deion Sanders Wants Fines for College Football Violations
2. Bill Bates
Bates was built for special teams chaos and delivered hits like he was auditioning for a demolition derby. In 2025, he’d be fined before the coin toss.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Ruthless NFL Defenders of All Time
1. Dick Butkus
The original football intimidator, Butkus, played like every play was a grudge match. In today’s sanitized NFL, he’d rack up fines faster than yards.
