Quarterbacks get all the glory, but sometimes they take it a step too far. These guys acted like they were the only ones on the field, forgetting the other 52 dudes in uniform trying to help them win games.
From hogging the spotlight to blaming teammates for losses, these quarterbacks occasionally treated the huddle like a one-man show. Here are 15 signal-callers who needed a gentle reminder that football is, in fact, a team sport.
15. Jay Cutler
Cutler had a cannon for an arm and a face that said, “I’d rather be anywhere else.” He rarely connected with his teammates emotionally, making it seem like he was playing his solo campaign.
14. Cam Newton
When Cam was on, he was electric. But when things went south, he could shift into “me first” mode and confuse the rest of the team.
13. Jeff George
The talent was there, no doubt. But George’s attitude often gave off strong “I’m better than this team” energy.
12. Deshaun Watson
Even before the off-field headlines, he was growing a reputation for seeing himself as bigger than the Texans. It’s hard to rally the locker room when your vibe screams “management problem.”
11. Kyler Murray
Kyler’s body language alone could clear out a locker room. Add rumors about his preparation habits, and you’ve got a QB who doesn’t always scream “team captain.”
10. Carson Wentz
Wentz looked like the guy in 2017—until things unraveled and whispers of locker room friction started to swirl. It felt like he wanted the leadership role without the collaboration that comes with it.
9. Johnny Manziel
Johnny Football was more of a one-man brand than a quarterback. He played like he was chasing highlight reels instead of wins.
8. Brett Favre
Favre was undeniably great, but he had moments where he acted like the team should adjust around him. Retirement, teases, and freelancing in the field didn’t always sit well with everyone else.
7. Jameis Winston
Jameis always believed in Jameis—maybe too much. He played like he was trying to win games single-handedly, even if that meant throwing five picks.
6. Jay Schroeder
Teammates reportedly didn’t love playing with him, and it showed. His leadership style (or lack thereof) gave off strong “me over we” vibes.
5. Josh Rosen
From the jump, Rosen gave off the aura of someone who thought he was smarter than the whole organization. That doesn’t usually work when you’re supposed to lead 10 other guys.
4. Aaron Rodgers
Rodgers has delivered plenty of magic, but he also loves reminding everyone how smart he is. When things go wrong, it’s rarely ever his fault—at least according to him.
3. Baker Mayfield
Baker always had the swagger, but sometimes it overshadowed the team dynamic. He was quick to chirp but slow to build chemistry when the going got tough.
2. Russell Wilson
Mr. Unlimited felt very limited regarding being one of the guys. Whether it was office perks in Denver or distancing himself in Seattle, Russ forgot the “team” part of teamwork. Here’s hoping his time in New York is better.
Read More: Ranking the 20 Most Self-Obsessed NFL Quarterbacks of All Time
1. Zach Wilson
When your team puts up three points and you say you didn’t let the defense down, you’ve officially forgotten the group project you’re in. Zach’s inability to own his role made it hard for anyone to rally behind him.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Conceited Quarterbacks Ever
