Winning in the NFL takes more than talent. It takes grit, leadership, a little bit of luck, and the kind of relentless mindset that turns close games into comeback stories.
These 20 stars didn’t just rack up stats, they made the difference when it mattered most. Whether it was a late-game drive, a clutch defensive stop, or just an aura that said “we’re not losing today,” these players always found a way to come out on top.
20. Joe Flacco
He may not have screamed “superstar,” but when the playoffs hit, Flacco was money. His 2012 run was one of the best postseason stretches ever, and he has the ring to prove it.
19. Derrick Brooks
The Buccaneers’ defense was loaded, but Brooks was the heart that kept it ticking. No matter the opponent, you could count on him to show up and make game-changing plays.
18. Kurt Warner
From grocery shelves to Super Bowl MVP, Warner’s story is pure Hollywood. He made every team he touched better, and when the lights got bright, he didn’t blink.
17. Ray Lewis
Lewis wasn’t just a linebacker, he was a force of nature. His leadership and passion fueled wins even when the Ravens’ offense was asleep at the wheel.
16. Russell Wilson
In his prime Seattle days, Wilson thrived in chaos and turned broken plays into victories. He made fourth quarters feel like his personal playground.
15. Charles Woodson
Whether it was at the corner or the safety, Woodson had a sixth sense for being in the right place. He made a career out of swinging momentum at just the right moment.
14. Troy Polamalu
With that hair flying around, you knew something wild was about to happen. Polamalu had a knack for the improbable, and the Steelers always benefited.
13. John Elway
He waited a long time for his Super Bowl moment, but when it came, he delivered back-to-back titles. Elway was built for big games and fourth-quarter magic.
12. Marshall Faulk
As the engine of the Greatest Show on Turf, Faulk did it all, and then some. If you needed a play, he’d make it happen, one way or another.
11. Reggie White
Offenses feared him for good reason, he could wreck a game plan by himself. When the Packers needed a stop, White brought the pressure.
10. Patrick Mahomes
Still in the early stages of his career, but he already has a resume most QBs would dream of. When the Chiefs need a win, Mahomes just finds a way, often with something jaw-dropping.
9. Steve Young
After waiting behind Joe Montana, Young made the most of his time in the spotlight. His legs, arms, and will to win helped bring another title to San Francisco.
8. Deion Sanders
He could shut down half the field and take a punt to the house on the same day. Deion was flashy, but more importantly, he was a winner.
7. Emmitt Smith
He didn’t always wow you with flash, but he just kept moving the chains. Smith’s consistency and durability were keys to the Cowboys’ 90s dynasty.
6. Ben Roethlisberger
Big Ben thrived in ugly, physical games and had a knack for late-game heroics. The Steelers always felt like contenders with him under center.
5. Joe Montana
Cool under pressure doesn’t even begin to describe him. Montana was the master of the two-minute drill and made winning feel routine.
4. Jerry Rice
Every time he stepped on the field, Rice raised the bar. His work ethic, clutch plays, and sheer dominance helped define a winning era in San Francisco.
3. Lawrence Taylor
He changed the way the game was played and ruined plenty of Sundays for opposing QBs. LT was relentless, and his presence alone made the Giants contenders.
Read More: Ranking the 20 Biggest “Me First” Quarterbacks in League History
2. Peyton Manning
One of the smartest to ever play, Manning turned preparation into points. Whether in Indy or Denver, he had a way of putting his team in the best position to win.
Read More: Ranking the 20 Best Quarterbacks Playing Right Now
1. Tom Brady
No one has won more or done it longer. Whether it was a game-winning drive or a Super Bowl comeback, Brady found ways to win that defied belief.
Read More: 15 NFL Quarterbacks Who Never Stopped Yelling
