The 10 Nicest Guys to Ever Play in the NFL

Football is a brutal, physical sport—but not every player brings that same intensity off the field. Some of the toughest guys on Sundays are the kindest, most genuine people the rest of the week.

Whether through community work, leadership, or just treating everyone with respect, these players built reputations as actual class acts. Here are 10 of the nicest guys to ever suit up in the NFL.

10. Jason Kelce

Jason Kelce
Wikimedia Commons

Known for his leadership and loyalty in Philly, Kelce is as kind off the field as he was fierce on it. He’s beloved by teammates, fans, and everyone who meets him.

9. Aeneas Williams

Aeneas Williams
Wikimedia Commons

Williams played with skill and smarts but also carried himself with grace throughout his Hall of Fame career. He’s been respected for his character as he was for his coverage.

8. Benjamin Watson

Benjamin Watson
Wikimedia Commons

A true pro on and off the field, Watson was always involved in charity work and thoughtful conversations. He used his platform to bring people together and lift others.

7. Steve Largent

Steve Largent
Openverse

Before he was a congressman, Largent was one of the most respected receivers in the league. Quiet, humble, and incredibly gracious, he earned praise from opponents and teammates.

6. Larry Fitzgerald

Larry Fitzgerald
Wikipedia

Fitzgerald might be the most universally liked wide receiver in NFL history. He played with class, respected the game, and gave back at every opportunity.

5. Tony Dungy

Tony Dungy
Flickr

Yes, he’s better now as a coach and analyst, but Dungy was a player first—and a good one. He’s always been a soft-spoken leader who leads with kindness and calm.

4. Peyton Manning

Peyton Manning
Wikimedia Commons

Manning was ultra-competitive but always found time to sign autographs, chat with fans, and support teammates. His humor and sportsmanship made him one of the game’s greatest fronts.

3. Reggie White

Reggie White
Flickr

The “Minister of Defense” was dominant between the lines and deeply respected away from them. His faith, kindness, and impact on the community left a lasting legacy.

2. Walter Payton

Walter Payton
Openverse

Sweetness wasn’t just a nickname—it was his entire vibe. He played hard, smiled often, and was known for his generosity and compassion.

1. Kurt Warner

Kurt Warner
Wikipedia

Warner went from stocking grocery shelves to Super Bowl MVP, never letting success change who he was. He treated everyone warmly and humbly and remains one of the most genuinely lovely guys ever to play the game.

Related Articles
East Rutherford, NJ -- June 5, 2025 -- Quarterbacks, JTommy DeVito, Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston as the New York Giants players participate in their 2025 OTAÕs at the Quest Diagnostic Giants Training Center in East Rutherford
Ranking the 10 Quarterback Battles That Could Define the 2025-26 NFL Season
From rookies with sky-high potential to veterans, these competitions could shake up charts, playoff races,...
Read More
Oct. 12, 2008; Glendale, AZ, USA; Dallas Cowboys wide receiver (81) Terrell Owens against the Arizona Cardinals at University of Phoenix Stadium. Arizona defeated Dallas 30-24 in overtime. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports
20 NFL Wide Receivers Who Always Acted Like Big Babies
From legendary divas to modern-day drama magnets, here’s a countdown of 20 NFL wide receivers who always...
Read More
Oct 22, 2000; Cincinnati, OH, USA; Denver Broncos linebacker Bill Romanowski (53) in action against the Cincinnati Bengals at Paul Brown Stadium. The Bengals beat the Broncos 31-21. Mandatory Credit: Matthew Emmons-Imagn Images
20 NFL Players Who Took 'Old-School' Way Too Literally
From fullbacks stuck in the ‘70s to linebackers who hit like it was still legal, here are 20 NFL players...
Read More

As an Amazon Associate, The Quick Report earns from qualifying purchases.

Part of the Castaway Studios media network.