Quarterbacks today are asked to do it all—move, create, throw on the run, and carry entire offenses on their shoulders. But believe it or not, there were plenty of guys slinging it before 2000 who would feel right at home in the modern NFL.
These are the quarterbacks who looked like they were playing in the wrong decade—in the best way. Whether it was their mobility, arm talent, or fearless playstyle, they were ahead of their time.
10. Neil O’Donnell
He wasn’t flashy, but he was steady and smart—just the kind of field general that still finds a role in today’s game. Think of him as the kind of guy who’d get plugged into a solid roster and just keep the machine moving.
9. Boomer Esiason
Boomer had the swagger, the lefty release, and the aggressive mindset that would play well today. He wasn’t afraid to air it out and loved to push the tempo—traits that scream modern football.
8. Bobby Hebert
A bit of a wild card, Hebert had a creative streak that feels right at home in today’s off-script-heavy offenses. He wasn’t always polished, but he made plays—and that’s half the battle these days.
7. Bernie Kosar
Kosar’s unorthodox style wouldn’t scare off today’s coaches—it’d probably intrigue them. He played with anticipation, guts, and a weirdly beautiful efficiency that modern analytics would absolutely love.
6. Randall Cunningham
Cunningham was practically a preview of what the 2020s quarterback would look like. He could run, throw deep, improvise like crazy, and make defensive coordinators lose sleep.
5. Doug Flutie
Flutie broke all the size rules and just kept balling. Today’s league has a soft spot for playmakers who don’t fit the mold, and Flutie would’ve been a fan favorite all over again.
4. Jim Kelly
Kelly ran a fast-paced offense before it was trendy and had the leadership to pull it off. He would’ve crushed it in today’s tempo-heavy, spread-style systems.
3. Fran Tarkenton
If Tarkenton had been born 30 years later, he’d be a dual-threat sensation. The dude was scrambling before it was fashionable and made backyard football look like a science.
Read More: Ranking Former NFL Quarterbacks Who Could Still Play in Today’s Game
2. Steve Young
Young was like a cheat code—deadly accurate, fast, and fearless. He’d be the prototype in today’s NFL and probably get paid half the salary cap.
Read More: The 10 Shortest Quarterbacks Who Ever Made NFL History
1. Warren Moon
Moon had the arm, the poise, and the vision to light up today’s game. He’d be throwing for 5,000 yards a year with ease—and probably doing it in style.
Read More: 15 Former NFL WRs Who Would Thrive in the Modern Game
