Quarterbacks don’t just throw passes—they lead teams, define franchises, and inspire fans. Some do it with sheer talent. Others with grit, humor, or an undeniable connection to the people who cheer them on.
But being likeable? That’s a different skill altogether.
Some QBs win over fans with heartwarming underdog stories. Others earn respect through their humility, leadership, and work in the community. No matter the path, the most likeable quarterbacks remind us that football is about more than just stats—it’s about character.
Here’s a look at some of the most universally beloved QBs, past and present.
The Underdogs Who Won Our Hearts
Nothing pulls fans in like a good comeback story. Few players have lived one quite like Kurt Warner. From stocking shelves at a grocery store to Super Bowl MVP, Warner’s story is pure Hollywood. But even with all the accolades, he never lost his down-to-earth personality. He stayed humble, grateful, and always quick to credit his teammates.
Similarly, Drew Brees proved that being overlooked can fuel greatness. He wasn’t the biggest or strongest QB, but his leadership and connection to New Orleans made him a hero. His work in the community—especially after Hurricane Katrina—cemented his place as one of the most beloved figures in sports.
Then there’s Josh Allen, the small-town kid from Wyoming who was told he’d never make it. He went from an unknown recruit to an NFL superstar, all while staying as goofy and relatable as ever. Whether he’s hurdling defenders or joking with teammates, Allen plays with joy—and that makes fans love him even more.
The Quiet Leaders Who Let Their Play Do the Talking
Some QBs don’t need to be flashy to be respected. Barry Sanders proved that at running back, but Andrew Luck did the same at quarterback. A football genius with an old-school attitude, Luck treated every opponent with respect—he even congratulated defenders who sacked him.
Another class act? Bart Starr. A true gentleman of the game, Starr led the Packers to early NFL dominance without ever making it about himself. He embodied sportsmanship, proving you could be both great and humble.
The Natural Entertainers
Not every quarterback stays quiet. Some win fans over by simply being hilarious.
Peyton Manning wasn’t just a football mastermind—he became a comedy legend. Whether it was his dry wit, unforgettable SNL skits, or legendary commercials, Manning made the NFL more fun. Even after retirement, he’s still one of the most entertaining figures in sports.
His longtime rival, Tom Brady, may have been a fiery competitor, but his post-retirement self has shown a surprisingly funny and self-aware side. Even those who rooted against him can’t deny his charm now.
And let’s not forget Terry Bradshaw, the original fun-loving QB. Whether winning Super Bowls for the Steelers or cracking jokes on TV, Bradshaw never took himself too seriously—making him one of football’s most enduring personalities.
The Fan Favorites Who Just Feel Like Good People
Some quarterbacks simply connect with people.
Joe Burrow, for example, has mastered the balance of confidence and humility. He’s cool under pressure, but he never makes it about himself. Whether he’s repping his hometown of Athens, Ohio, or speaking up for good causes, he feels genuine—and fans love that.
Lamar Jackson brings that same energy. His electrifying play makes him exciting to watch, but his humble, team-first mentality makes him easy to root for. Despite the pressure, he always puts fun first, and that’s contagious.
Even quarterbacks from past eras, like Johnny Unitas, left lasting impressions not just with their talent, but with their humility and work ethic. Unitas wasn’t just a great player—he was the blueprint for how to be a pro.
More Than Just Quarterbacks
At the end of the day, the most likeable quarterbacks aren’t just the ones who win—they’re the ones who inspire. Whether it’s their underdog stories, leadership, humor, or connection to their communities, these players remind us why we love football.
Stats and records fade, but character lasts forever. And that’s why these QBs will always be fan favorites.
Related: The Most Likable Stars Playing in the NFL Right Now
