Defense wins championships—or at least it wins you a spot on this list. Over the years, Major League Baseball has seen some absolutely ridiculous defensive wizards who made the impossible look routine.
From legendary shortstops to outfielders who robbed home runs for fun, these are the 15 best defensive players in MLB history.
15. Joe Tinker (SS)
A key part of the legendary Tinker-to-Evers-to-Chance double-play combo for the early 1900s Chicago Cubs, Joe Tinker was a defensive maestro at shortstop. His quick hands and smooth footwork helped redefine infield defense in baseball’s dead-ball era.
14. Willie McCovey (1B)
First base isn’t always a position associated with elite defense, but Willie McCovey made it look easy. His stretch at the bag, soft hands, and ability to dig out bad throws made life a lot easier for his infielders.
13. Scott Rolen (3B)
If there was a Gold Glove for making insane barehanded plays and diving stops, Scott Rolen would have won it every year. The Hall of Fame third baseman had a rocket arm, incredible range, and the instincts to turn hot shots down the line into routine outs.
12. Johnny Bench (C)
No list of defensive greats is complete without a catcher, and Johnny Bench was the gold standard. His cannon of an arm shut down base-stealers, and he had an unmatched ability to frame pitches and block balls in the dirt.
11. Keith Hernandez (1B)
Another first baseman on the list? Absolutely. Keith Hernandez won 11 Gold Gloves and practically invented modern first base defense. His ability to charge bunts, make quick tags, and play deep without sacrificing range was revolutionary.
10. Andruw Jones (CF)
If you hit a ball to center field against the Braves in the late ‘90s and early 2000s, Andruw Jones probably caught it. His jumps, routes, and ability to make running grabs were second to none. He made Gold Glove-caliber defense look effortless.
9. Brooks Robinson (3B)
There’s a reason he’s called “The Human Vacuum Cleaner.” Brooks Robinson’s glove work at third base for the Orioles was the stuff of legend. He made diving stops, backhand plays, and off-balance throws look easy for 23 seasons.
8. Ozzie Smith (SS)
They don’t call him “The Wizard” for nothing. Ozzie Smith could turn double plays with magic, flip in the air for fun, and cover more ground than seemed humanly possible. His 13 Gold Gloves prove he was more than just flash—he was pure skill.
7. Ivan Rodriguez (C)
“Pudge” had a howitzer attached to his right shoulder. If you even thought about stealing a base against Ivan Rodriguez, you were probably out. His defensive prowess behind the plate made him one of the best all-around catchers ever.
6. Adrián Beltré (3B)
Adrián Beltré mixed elite defense with a legendary sense of humor. But when it came to the hot corner, nobody worked harder. His quick reflexes, strong arm, and ability to make plays from deep at third made him a defensive icon.
5. Yadier Molina (C)
The master of the backpick, Yadier Molina owned the running game. His arm strength, pitch-calling, and ability to control an entire defense from behind the plate made him one of the best defensive catchers of all time.
4. Roberto Clemente (RF)
Watching Roberto Clemente throw a baseball was like watching art in motion. His cannon of an arm from right field gunned down runners with ease, and his fearless outfield play made him one of the greatest defensive right fielders ever.
3. Ichiro Suzuki (RF)
Ichiro’s speed, arm, and precision made him one of the greatest defensive outfielders in history. Whether it was robbing home runs or hosing runners at third base with laser throws, Ichiro had it all.
2. Willie Mays (CF)
“The Catch.” Enough said. But Willie Mays was so much more than that one legendary play. His ability to track down balls in the deepest parts of the outfield, his instincts, and his arm made him one of the best defensive players in history.
Read More: Ranking the 30 Greatest Golfers of All Time
1. Greg Maddux (P)
Wait—a pitcher at No. 1? You bet. Greg Maddux won an absurd 18 Gold Gloves, more than any player in history. His ability to field his position, cut off ground balls, and control the game with his defense made him the best defensive player MLB has ever seen.
Read More: The 15 Best MLB Rookie Seasons Ever
