Behind the fame and fortune, a handful of NFL players have committed crimes that shocked fans and ruined their legacies forever. Conspiracy, violence, and reckless behavior — these individuals show off how quickly a promising career can spiral into infamy. Let’s take a closer look at 8 NFL players whose actions led to felony convictions, some prison time, and public disgrace, proving that even the brightest stars can fall.
Rae Carruth — Conspiracy to Commit Murder
Rae Carruth, a former wide receiver for the Carolina Panthers, went from NFL stardom to infamy. He was convicted of conspiring to murder his pregnant girlfriend, Cherica Adams, in 2001. Carruth wanted to avoid paying child support, and this led him to making a truly evil decision.
He hired someone to carry out the crime, which resulted in a tragic loss. Cherica was able to call for help before she passed, leaving behind a son born prematurely. Carruth served nearly two decades in prison and was released in 2018. His case remains one of the darkest in football history.
Darren Sharper — Sexual Assault
Darren Sharper, a former NFL safety, had a career many would envy. But his legacy was shattered by his criminal actions. In 2016, he was convicted of drugging and assaulting women in multiple states.
Sharper’s actions shocked fans and the league alike. Once celebrated for his skills on the field, he became infamous for his crimes. He is serving an 18-year prison sentence, and his name is now a cautionary tale of abuse of power and trust.
Greg Hardy — Domestic Violence
Greg Hardy, a former defensive end for the Panthers and Cowboys, saw his career unravel after a domestic violence case. In 2014, he was found guilty of assaulting his ex-girlfriend, though the case later fell apart when the victim didn’t appear in court.
The NFL still took action, suspending Hardy for part of the 2015 season. His behavior off the field overshadowed his talent, and teams were reluctant to work with him. Hardy’s football career ended in controversy, leaving a damaged legacy behind.
Michael Vick — Dogfighting
Michael Vick, a superstar quarterback, stunned the world when his involvement in a dogfighting ring came to light. In 2007, he was convicted of running an illegal operation that shocked animal lovers everywhere.
Fans couldn’t believe the news — Vick had been a beloved figure in football. He served nearly two years in prison and later tried to rebuild his image. While he eventually returned to the NFL, the shadow of his crimes never fully left him.
Aaron Hernandez — Murder
Aaron Hernandez, a former Patriots tight end, had a bright future that ended in tragedy. In 2015, he was convicted of murdering Odin Lloyd, a man connected to Hernandez through family ties.
Evidence quickly linked Hernandez to the crime, and his trial captivated the public. Once a rising star in the NFL, he was sentenced to life in prison without parole. His story came to an even sadder end when he was found dead in his cell in 2017.
O.J. Simpson — Armed Robbery and Kidnapping
O.J. Simpson’s post-NFL life was filled with legal troubles. While best known for his controversial 1995 trial, he later went to prison for a different crime. In 2007, Simpson was convicted of armed robbery and kidnapping after attempting to recover his memorabilia by force.
He served nine years in prison before being released on parole in 2017. Simpson’s turbulent history kept him in the public eye until his death in 2024.
Related: Scandal in the Corner Office: 10 CEOs Who Totally Blew It
Henry Ruggs III — DUI Resulting in Death
Henry Ruggs III was a rising NFL star with the Las Vegas Raiders. But in 2021, his career and life changed forever. Ruggs caused a fatal crash while driving under the influence, killing a young woman and her dog.
The crash was heartbreaking and avoidable. Ruggs faced multiple charges and a potential long prison sentence. His story is a sobering reminder of how quickly bad choices can destroy lives.
Related: The 10 Biggest Sports Scandals In History
Lawrence Phillips — Assault and Attempted Murder
Lawrence Phillips was a talented running back whose potential was overshadowed by his behavior. His career was marked by repeated legal troubles, including domestic violence and assault charges.
In 2009, Phillips was convicted of driving his car into a group of teenagers and sentenced to 31 years in prison. While incarcerated, he faced additional charges for the death of his cellmate. Phillips’ life ended in tragedy, with his death ruled a suicide in 2016. His story is one of wasted talent and needless violence.
Related: The 10 Strangest Celebrity Run-Ins With the Law
